The Case for Phasing Out PMS Subsidies!
By Saleh Shehu Ashaka
Navigating Energy Security and Sustainability The debate surrounding the complete phasing out of fuel subsidies, particularly for Premium Motor Spirit (PMS), is both timely and critical as we grapple with energy security, economic stability, and the urgent need for a sustainable energy future in Nigeria. As highlighted by industry leaders like Aliko Dangote, the crux of this issue lies not just in removing subsidies but in ensuring that our energy framework fundamentally supports domestic capacity and promotes a transition toward cleaner alternatives.
Nigeria’s struggle with fuel subsidies is far from new. The government’s efforts to remove subsidies have been marred by political backtracking and unsustainable fiscal practices. The Jonathan administration’s removal of PMS subsidies in 2014, accompanied by initiatives such as the SURE-P program, ultimately failed to bring lasting change, leading to a resurgence of “under recovery” scenarios.
Fast forward to President Tinubu’s assertion of an end to subsidies, only to be confronted with a staggering $6 billion in outstanding subsidy payments. This cycle points to a systemic failure rooted in our lack of energy security—specifically, our inability to refine oil domestically on a scale that meets our citizens’ needs.
The recent completion of the Dangote Refinery provides a glimmer of hope in addressing Nigeria’s energy security challenge. By significantly increasing domestic refining capacity, we can reduce our dependence on imported fuels and the associated economic vulnerabilities.
However, merely having a refinery is not a panacea; we must ensure that it operates efficiently and is integrated into a broader strategy for energy sustainability.
Read Also:
Without energy security, any efforts to eliminate subsidies will likely lead to new forms of economic strain on Nigerians. Rising fuel prices could exacerbate inflation and worsen living conditions, especially for low-income families who are already grappling with high costs of goods and services. Therefore, the timing of subsidy removal must be aligned with tangible improvements in domestic refining and market dynamics to cushion the impact on consumers.
While the immediate concern revolves around pricing and affordability, the longer-term perspective must focus on transitioning toward a more sustainable energy model. This involves investing in clean and renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, and biofuels alongside expanding the use of natural gas, Compressed Natural Gas (CNG), and Liquefied Petroleum Gas (LPG).
These alternatives not only mitigate environmental impacts but also diversify our energy portfolio, reducing reliance on a single resource.
The government should spearhead initiatives to incentivize private investments in renewable energy, thus fostering a competitive marketplace that prioritizes innovation and sustainability. Public-private partnerships could play a crucial role in developing infrastructure and technology necessary for this transition.
Ensuring affordability during this transition is pivotal. Policymakers must consider implementing targeted social safety nets that protect the most vulnerable populations from price shocks.
These could include direct cash transfers, subsidies for public transport, or tax relief measures to alleviate the burden on low-income households.
Moreover, as we phase out PMS subsidies, clear communication is essential. Engaging with citizens, explaining the rationale behind these changes, and demonstrating a commitment to invest in renewable energy and domestic capacity will be vital for maintaining public trust and cooperation.
As Nigeria navigates these complex dynamics, the call for a complete phasing out of PMS subsidies presents an opportunity to reshape our energy landscape. By focusing on enhancing energy security through domestic refining and embracing a diverse energy mix, we can lay the groundwork for a sustainable future. While the path may be fraught with challenges, a decisive commitment to reform and investment can transform Nigeria’s energy sector and benefit its citizens in the long run. The time for discussion has passed; the time for action has arrived.
